1. Mercedes – All I Want For Christmas Is You
2. Blaine & Rachel – Extraordinary Merry Christmas
3. Santana – Santa Baby
4. Emma & Will – Christmas Eve With You
5. Artie – Little Drummer Boy
6. Rachel – River
7. Harmony & Alex Newell – Do You Hear What I Hear
8. Blaine & Kurt – Let It Snow
9. Puck & Finn – Santa Claus Is Coming To Town
10. Brittany – Christmas Wrapping
11. Rory – Blue Christmas
12. All – Do They Know It’s Christmas